Friday, March 11, 2005

Charles Krauthammer: Three Cheers for the Bush Doctrine. History has begun to speak, and it says that America made the right decision to invade Iraq. on Stewart, the sage of Comedy Central, is one of the few to be honest about it. "What if Bush ... has been right about this all along? I feel like my world view will not sustain itself and I may ... implode." Daniel Schorr, another critic of the Bush foreign policy, ventured, a bit more grudgingly, that Bush "may have had it right." Right on what? That America, using power harnessed to democratic ideals, could begin a transformation of the Arab world from endless tyranny and intolerance to decent governance and democratization. Two years ago, shortly before the invasion of Iraq, I argued in these pages that forcefully deposing Saddam Hussein was, more than anything, about America "coming ashore" to effect a "pan-Arab reformation"--a dangerous, "risky and, yes, arrogant" but necessary attempt to change the very culture of the Middle East, to open its doors to democracy and modernity. [...] (Time Magazine)

M. A. Muqtedar Khan: The Bush administration is under the false impression that the elections in Iraq herald the era of democracy in Iraq and thus justify the Bush preemption doctrine. What they cannot see is that the US has just facilitated a major transfer of power in the Arab World - from Sunnis to Shiites. Thanks to the US the Arab Shites will now control Baghdad - the jewel in the Islamic crown - after a millennium. They did not rule over Baghdad even under the glorious Fatimid Dynasty (909-1171), a Shiite dynasty that ruled over Egypt, North Africa and Syria nearly a thousand years ago but had a tenuous hold briefly under the Buwayhid tribal confederation from 945-1055 when the Turkic Seljuks invaded and captured Baghdad with the help of the Abbasids. (Pakistan Link via Pacific News Service)

United States President George W. Bush is this week claiming that his foreign policy is working to drive democracy in the Middle East, citing changes in Lebanon, Egypt and of course Iraq. But a prominent Australian Middle East expert at the Lowy Institute for International Policy, who has just returned from the region, is warning that the West is in danger of missing the point if it sees the democratisation of the Middle East through a US foreign policy prism. In a research paper to be released next week, Anthony Bubalo argues that Islamism, so much feared by the west as the source of international terrorism and opposed by key Bush administration advisers, can itself be a democratising force. (ABC News Online)

Iraq’s Jan. 30 elections gave a huge boost to the confidence and reputation of the country’s new security forces, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff told Congress March 10. “Security for Iraqi elections was done primarily by Iraqi security forces, both inner and outer cordons,” Air Force Gen. Richard B. Myers told the House Armed Services Committee. “There were, I think, 11 suicide bombers that attempted to penetrate. None of them did.” Iraqi security forces -- the Iraqi police, special police units and the Iraqi army -- provided the bulk of security around more than 5,000 polling places. Coalition forces only become involved in the security picture in a few areas of Anbar province, most notably Fallujah. (US Dept. of Defense)

Sunday, March 06, 2005

Iraq's dominant Shiite-led alliance set a mid-March deadline to form a government, prodded to action yesterday by spiritual leader Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Husseini al-Sistani, who demanded progress after more than a month of postelection haggling. Members of the United Iraqi Alliance, the big winner in the Jan. 30 legislative elections, met in central Baghdad and agreed to try to form a government and convene the 275-member National Assembly by March 15 - after Sistani demanded that they stop bickering. (AP via Philadelphia Inquirer)

Iraq's newly elected National Assembly will convene for the first time on March 16 even if complete agreement on a new government has not been reached, political leaders said Sunday. "They decided together that the assembly will be held on the 16th of this month," said Jawad Taki, spokesman for a leading Islamist party that met Saturday with other political groups and selected the date. Barham Salih, a Kurdish politician and interim deputy prime minister, told Reuters news agency that the assembly would hold its first meeting on that day whether or not total agreement had been reached on a government. The parties "hope to reach an agreement by then," he said. "If we don't . . . the National Assembly will begin its work and discussions will continue inside the assembly." (Washington Post)

Leadership stalemate grips Iraq. Iraq will hold a meeting of its newly elected National Assembly in 10 days with or without a new government, the deputy prime minister said, hoping to instill a sense of order amid the daily violence. Five weeks after elections, the lack of agreement between leading parties over who will lead the new government has fanned fears insurgent activity will spiral unchecked. Deputy Prime Minister Barham Salih Sunday said he hoped politicians would end horse-trading over top posts before the meeting. (The Standard [China])

Saturday, March 05, 2005

Two newly elected politicians announced today that they were withdrawing from the fragile political alliance cobbled together by the country's most powerful Shiite cleric, marking the first notable fracture within the alliance. The defections expose the vulnerability of the Shiite parties even as they are struggling to form a coalition government with other political groups, and showed the limits of the influence of Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, the cleric who assembled the alliance. The split signaled that any talks to form a new government will likely be protracted, as rivals to the Shiites try to take advantage of weaknesses in the alliance. (New York Times)

The spiritual leader of Iraq's Shiite majority said Saturday that the clergy-led United Iraqi Alliance must finally unite and form a government one month after the country's first democratic elections. In the Shiite holy city of Najaf, al-Sistani appealed for unity among the alliance's 140 parliamentary deputies after two of its leaders dropped out to protest its inability to barter a deal with other parties - including the Kurds, who control 75 seats - to form a coalition government. (AP)

The outgoing Iraqi prime minister Iyad Allawi, whose list scored third in the recent elections, affirmed his interest in keeping his job on Friday, after a party bolted the winning Shia political list. The defection of the National Coalition Movement from the United Iraqi Alliance (UIA) could be a boon for Allawi, whose hopes rest on splitting the Shia list and then cutting a deal with the Kurds. (The News [Pakistan])

A powerful Kurdish coalition said on Saturday that it would not back Iraq's main Shi'ite alliance in the race for prime minister without assurances that they would not impose an Islamic fundamentalist state. "Political Islam is a fact in our country. But I don't want Iraq to be tUrned into a religious, sectarian, fundamentalist state, this will not be accepted," said Barham Salih, deputy prime minister of Iraq and senior negotiator for the Kurdish bloc. (Reuters)

Friday, March 04, 2005

Talks aimed at forging an Iraq coalition government have faltered over Kurdish demands for more land and concerns that the dominant Shiite alliance seeks to establish an Islamic state, delaying the planned first meeting of Iraq’s new parliament. (scotsman.com)

Iraq elections prove that insurgency has no political future: Rice (politicalgateway.com)

Last month's balloting in Iraq is reverberating throughout the Middle East, top US Senator John McCain said, citing just-called multi-candidate presidential elections in Egypt Egypt as the most recent example of the regional sea change. (Designerz.com)

Dov S. Zakheim: Careful What You Wish For. Elections could yield hostile fanatics instead of freedom-loving friends. The successful national elections in Palestine and Iraq, along with local elections in Saudi Arabia and continuing demonstrations in Beirut reminiscent of those in Kiev not long ago, point to an upheaval in the Middle East. Yet in none of these places is it clear that democracy will endure. It isn't even apparent that Iraq's elections mark the beginning of a secular trend toward freedom of speech, assembly and religion. After all, these elections were not the first in Iraq's history, and the previous ones were followed by a series of nasty dictatorships, of which Saddam Hussein's was the most recent and nastiest. The leading candidate for prime minister, Ibrahim Jafari, is a member of the U.S.-backed interim government and head of the Shiite-based Islamic Dawa Party. He is a staunch advocate of Islamic values and has ties to Iran. It's anyone's guess what his policies might be if he does become prime minister. [...] (LA Times)

Yes, It's All Bush's Fault. For more than three years, the Left has characterised the War on Terror, and especially the liberation of Iraq, as "Bush's War." They've also referred to Iraq as "Bush's Adventure," "Bush's Crusade" and "Bush's Folly." They were calling it "Bush's Hastily Planned, Poorly Realised and Badly Executed Diversion From the 'Real' War," but pretty much stopped when they realised that it wouldn't all fit on a Volvo-sized bumper sticker. Liberals don't understand the strategy of defeating terrorism by changing the totalitarian governments that support it. They don't get the concept that freedom reduces frustration, which in turn reduces the ability of terrorist groups to recruit. They refuse to acknowledge that Congress voted the Authorisation for Use of Military Force Against Iraq into law. They insist that the war was all Bush's idea (when they don't consider him a puppet, that is), and that every setback and problem is all Bush's fault. (Men's News Daily)

Sunday, February 27, 2005

Taking a break from the seriousness of the world, here is a little humor:

Election Leaves Iraq in 'Quagmire of Compromise'. Results of the recent democratic elections in Iraq show that voters failed to fill the power vacuum created when Saddam Hussein's Baathist regime was overthrown, and instead elected a national assembly "destined to be a quagmire of compromise."

"How can this government achieve anything without a dominant political party backed by a fiercely loyal military?" said an unnamed Iraq expert at a non-partisan American think tank, "I'm afraid you're going to hear nothing but talk and concessions from this assembly."

Friday, February 25, 2005

The Jan. 30 elections in Iraq "put an end to any moral legitimacy the insurgents may have had," the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff said during a news conference here today. (US Dept. of Defense)

Iraq's deadly insurgency will rage on, no matter what the outcome of next month's elections may be, US Secretary of State Colin Powell said, amid new questions about the polls after a boycott call by the main Sunni Muslim party. (US politics at Designerz.com)

After the Iraq elections, the dealmaking begins. (Monday Morning)

Trudy Rubin: A minority must accept less power. Here's what fascinates me the most about the electoral experiment going on in Iraq: It tests whether the Arab world can move beyond regarding politics as a zero-sum game. In recent Arab history, winners take all, and losers go to jail. ''This is the first time ever that power has been transferred without a coup, a killing or a hereditary shift,'' a senior Iraqi official told me by phone, ``with the single exception of Lebanon.'' [...] (Miami Herald)

Allan Wall: National Question Real Victor In Iraq Elections. Twenty-two months after the overthrow of Saddam Hussein, Iraq held an election. Voters chose a provisional assembly charged with drafting the country's permanent constitution. I am currently in Iraq, serving with my National Guard unit. We were here on Election Day and did our duty. So I played my small part in this historic occasion. Saddam Hussein was a mass-murdering megalomaniac who deserved to be overthrown. But what kind of Iraq will emerge now? That's what remains to be seen. In order to appreciate the challenges Iraq faces, we have to recognize what kind of country it really is. Iraq is a 20th-century multicultural concoction. [...] (Memo From Mesopotamia at VDare.com)

Poll: Americans not convinced Iraqi elections have hastened U.S. troops departure timing. (AP via Boston Globe)

Thursday, February 24, 2005

The number of coalition military forces killed by hostile actions has declined significantly since Iraq's Jan. 30 election, according to military officials. (KRT Wire)

Iraqi elections draw varying opinions. President's role seen differently. (The East Carolinian)

Bashdar Ismaeel: Democracy, act 1. The much hailed and maligned milestone for the staging of democratic elections in Iraq on January 30 has now passed. On the surface, a remarkable milestone has been set. This represents the first democratic election in Iraq for more than 50 years and signifies a glimmer of hope that a true democracy, seemingly a traditional taboo in the Middle East, can prevail, even in the face of the conspicuous ethnic mosaic in Iraq. Just as important for the US in particular, the elections convey a strong message against the fight on terrorism, that the will of the people can overcome insurgency, oppression and trepidation. For many Iraqis, with a newfound feeling of freedom and optimism, going to the polls was too good an opportunity to turn down, even in the face of possible death. [...] (Asia Times)

Juan Cole on Ibrahim al-Jaafari, the Iraqi Elections and the Future of Islamic Law in Iraq (Democracy Now!)

Letter: Iraq elections over, future in doubt (Gloucester Daily Times)

Faleh A. Jabar: The Paradoxes of Iraq's Election Last] Sunday's announcement, 13 days after the poll took place, of the results of Iraq's first contested elections in half a century, will determine the make up of local provincial government, the Kurdish regional government and, most importantly, the constituent assembly charged with drafting the permanent constitution. (PoliticalAffairs.net)

Editorial excerpt: On the success of Iraq's elections. The Iraqi election results . . . revealed that 58 percent of registered voters cast their ballots. This was remarkably brave, considering the intense violence and intimidation against the poll by insurgents. The results prove many things; above all that the insurgency is not a popular uprising against the U.S.-led occupation. Most Iraqis probably want the Americans and their allies to leave, but would prefer to effect that peacefully -- through the ballot. . . . So it's still a long road to freedom. But at least Iraqi democracy now has a chance, which it did not have when Saddam Hussein was holding sway. Whatever happens now, the elections proved what should perhaps have been obvious, that democracy and the love of freedom are universal values. From Soweto, to Harare to Basra, if you give people even half a run at a ballot box, they will take it. (The Star, Johannesburg, South Africa via Miami Herald)

Wednesday, February 23, 2005

In a sign that political jockeying for the job of Iraqi prime minister isn't over, Interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi on Wednesday named a new coalition to challenge Ibrahim al-Jaafari for the post. At a news conference with other supporters, Allawi indicated his backing is broader than the list he fielded in January's election, but he didn't provide details. (CNN)

Tuesday, February 22, 2005

The United Iraqi Alliance, Iraq's main Shiite political coalition, has named Ibrahim al-Jaafari as its nominee to be the country's next prime minister, an Iraqi political official said.

The official, a member of the Supreme Council of the Islamic Revolution in Iraq, said that Ahmad Chalabi, another candidate for the post, dropped out of consideration. Al-Jaafari told CNN last week that he would accept the prime minister position if he was offered it. (CNN)

Saturday, February 19, 2005

A Shiite alliance won a slim majority in Iraq's new National Assembly, according to certified election returns announced Thursday, but it may take weeks to form a government. Meanwhile, interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi cautioned against excluding all Saddam Hussein's supporters. Allawi told The Associated Press that the alliance must change its platform of purging Sunnis who were members of Saddam's Baath Party from government positions if it wants national unity. (Salt Lake Tribune)

K Gajendra Singh: Iraqi Kurds Flex Muscles, Rice Was No Turkish Delight (Al Jazeera)

The Nation: Disharmony in Kurdistan

(recap) Iraq's Shiite Alliance Forms Majority (AP via The Moscow Times)